TOP 10 Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies: Comparison Chart
Best Overall: Glow in the Dark - MAM Night Orthodontic Pacifiers Review
Searching for your baby's pacifier in the darkness can be quite challenging in the dark especially when you are still sleepy. Turning on the light to search for the pacifier is also not such a good idea as it often makes your baby more irritated. This overall best pacifier solves this problem as it is made with glow in the dark features.
The MAM Night Orthodontic Pacifier which has the glow-in-the-dark feature also has soft nipples. Also, it comes with a sterilizing case. Another awesome feature of this pacifier is that it comes with holes that help your baby with ventilation.
Summary: This nipple like pacifier solves the problem of having to search for the pacifier in the middle of the night with its glow in the dark feature. It also features a storage case making it easier to clean the pacifier after each use.
Why We Like It
- Has the glow-in-the-dark feature
- Has soft nipples
- Aids better ventilation
- Comes with a sterilizing storage case
Budget: Affordable: Dr. Brown’s HappyPaci 100% Silicone Pacifier Review
This best pacifier for breastfed baby is lightweight and as such can be easily held by your baby. It is also very comfortable as it is made with silicone design.
The pacifiers come in one piece so there's no room for germs and bacteria to get in contact with your baby through it. It is also quite easy to clean as it cannot be affected negatively by any wash methods. This pacifier can also be washed by dishwasher so you don't have to worry about getting it cleaned. Additionally, the affordable pacifier is BPA free so you can be sure that your baby would be safe.
Summary: This pacifier is lightweight so your baby can hold it easily. Also, it is quite affordable even though its cheap price doesn't affect its quality in any way.
Why We Like It
- Comfortable design
- Cheap price
- BPA free
- Different models for different age grades
For Beginner: Pacifier Clip: MAM Pacifier for Breastfeed Babies Review
This best pacifier for breastfed babies is beginner friendly as it features a pacifier clip so it won't get misplaced. Since it is BPA free, it is safe for the usage of your newborn baby.
Also, the best pacifier for breastfed baby features SkinSoft silicone which has a natural feel that imitates breasts. The silicone is tasteless, clear, odorless and durable which easily makes it the best for your breastfed baby.
Another amazing feature of this best pacifier is that it includes large holes to aid better airflow for your baby.
Summary: This pacifier features a pacifier clip and this makes it easier for it to be found even if it gets misplaced. It is soft, durable and also imitates the natural feel of breasts. Also, it features large holes to allow better airflow for your baby.
Why We Like It
- Tasteless and odorless
- Soft and durable
- Features a pacifier clip
- It has large holes to aid better airflow
Gentle on the Gum: Nanobebe Pacifier Review
With its amazing features, the Nanobebe is easily one of the best pacifiers for your breastfed baby. Having a unique design that fits perfectly on your baby's mouth, it is obvious that this nipple shaped pacifier is one that your baby would be comfortable using.
Also, the pacifier has been proven safe for the use of children as it is produced from BPA- and phthalate-free silicone. Other awesome features of the pacifier are that not only it helps aid healthy oral development in babies, it is also soft and gentle on the gums and teeth.
Summary: This pacifier is not only BPA free but also soft and gentle on the gums. It is also mainly for the use of babies who are 6 months old or less.
- Soft nipple
- Lightweight design
- BPA- and phthalate-free
- Unique shape
- It cannot be used by older babies
Big Handle: Chicco PhysioForma Pacifier for Babies 0-6 Months Review
The design of the pacifier is a clinically tested one which has been proven to aid not just your baby's breathing but also their oral development. To further ensure the safety of your child, the pacifier was made from 100% BPA- and Latex-free hygienic silicone that makes the silicone safe for your baby. It also features a big handle that helps your baby in grasping the pacifier.
The presence of holes allows for easy breathing for your baby.
Summary: This pacifier is BPA and Latex free and also designed to aid your baby's breathing. It also features a big handle, making it easy for you as a baby to grasp the pacifier.
- 100% BPA- and Latex-free
- Big handle
- Aids baby's breathing and oral development
- Has sterilizing case
- Slightly big size
Convenient Design: Ryan and Rose Cutie PAT Pacifier Stage 1 Review
This pacifier for breastfed babies has a convenient design that serves - not only as a pacifier - but also as teething for your baby. This is one of the most nipple like pacifiers that has a natural feel, thereby imitating breastfeeding and satisfying your baby even more.
This is a good pacifier for breastfed babies as it is made with 100% medical-grade silicone that’s also free of BPA, latex, PVC, and phthalates thereby making it safe for your baby's use.
Another awesome feature of this pacifier is that it is approved by the FDA and US CPSIA compliant which makes it perfectly safe for your baby's usage.
Summary: This newborn pacifier for breastfed babies has a soft nipple that imitates the natural feel of the breast. It is US CPSIA compliant & FDA Approved and as several colors from which you can choose.
- BPA, PVC, and phthalate-free
- US CPSIA compliant & FDA Approved
- Several colors
- Convenient design
- A bit expensive
Detachable: Philips Avent Soothie Snuggle Pacifier Review
This Smoothie pacifier is light-weighted, thereby easy for your baby to grasp. The best pacifier for breastfed baby can also be detached for easy cleaning.
Another feature of this best pacifier for breastfed babies is that it is made of BPA-free and medical-grade silicone which makes it safe for your baby's use.
Additionally, it includes the orthodontic silicone nipple that is easily one of the best.
Summary: This best natural pacifier for breastfed babies is light-weighted, making it easy for your baby to grasp it. It can also be detached for easy cleaning. Additionally, the soothie pacifier for breastfed babies is made of BPA free silicone.
- Soft and lightweight
- Features medical-grade silicone
- Easy to clean
- BPA-free silicone
- It can be easily removed by babies
Large holes that prevent bacteria: Bibs Natural Rubber Pacifier Review
Bibs Natural Rubber Pacifier has a well-rounded nipple that feels as natural as possible. The pacifier is made of natural rubber and this helps it in imitating the natural feel.
The best pacifier is also made from materials that are free from toxic chemicals - like BPA, PVC, and phthalates that can cause harm to your child.
As harmless as it may seem, having saliva trapped underneath a pacifier for breastfed newborn can be quite harmful. Bacteria can get introduced through this and it might cause skin irritation. To prevent this major problem, this pacifier has three open holes around the shield. This helps air flow freely in and out of the shield.
Summary: This pacifier features modern and classic designs. Also, it has three large holes so that saliva doesn't get trapped in the pacifier as this could attract skin-irritating bacteria.
- Beautiful colors
- Prevents bacteria
- Natural rubber
- Free from toxic chemicals
- Long nipples
Resealable steam Sanitation Bag: Evenflo Feeding Balance Plus Stage 1 Cylindrical Baby, Newborn and Infant Pacifier Review
With a simple yet elegant design, this orthodontic pacifier for breastfed babies has been designed specifically for babies of 0 to 6 months. One of the main functions of this best pacifier is that it aids and encourages healthy sucking skills in your baby.
The nipple of the pacifier is made in the cylindrical shape so that it gives space for your baby to use their tongue efficiently while sucking. This pacifier is a one-piece object which makes it practically impossible for the pacifier to fall apart thereby choking the baby.
Also, the pacifier for breastfed newborn is made of materials that are free from toxic chemicals. Additionally, the pacifier contains a re-sealable steam sanitation bag for easy cleaning. Lastly, the presence of large ventilation holes on the pacifier allows the baby to breathe conveniently.
Summary: This pacifier features a resealable steam sanitation bag that aids in cleaning. Also, it has lava holes for easy breathing for your baby.
- One-piece pacifier
- Large ventilation holes
- Features Resealable steam sanitation bag
- BPA free
- Can discolor easily
Dishwasher Safe: Itzy Ritzy Sweetie Soother Pacifiers Review
This best pacifier for breastfed baby is a one-piece pacifier that helps mainly in soothing your baby. Each of the small pacifiers for breastfed babies comes with a uniquely cute design that can easily match your baby's outfit.
The pacifier features two large holes that your child is breathing even while sucking for a prolonged period. The pacifier is made with 100% food-grade and latex-free silicone that's soft enough for your baby to suck conveniently on it. This pacifier can also be cleaned and sterilized with a dishwasher.
Summary: The pacifier is a one-piece pacifier that comes in several cute designs. It also features large holes for early breathing. Additionally, the pacifier is dishwasher safe.
- Two large holes for easy breathing
- Cute designs
- 100% food-grade and latex-free silicone
- Not quite durable
Buyer’s Guide: All You Need to Know About the Best Pacifier for Breastfed Baby
There are a lot of pacifiers in the market and not all of them feature premium functions. Since your baby deserves nothing but the best, scouting the market for the best brand of pacifier for breastfed babies might be quite difficult if you don’t know what to look for in a pacifier before purchasing it. Our professional reviewers have gone the extra length to bring the best pacifier for breastfed baby 2020 to guide your choice.
Should you give a breastfed baby a pacifier
While some babies are content being rocked or cuddled to sleep, other babies just can’t get enough of sucking. Since you cannot always breastfeed your baby even when he or she doesn’t need it, you might have to get a pacifier.
Another awesome reason why you should get your baby a pacifier is that a study has shown that babies who use pacifiers are less likely to run the risk of SIDS (sudden infant death syndrome).
When to introduce pacifier to breastfeeding baby
It is preferable to wait until your baby has adopted a solid feeding pattern and established latching before introducing the pacifier.
How to get a breastfed baby to take a pacifier
Since two babies cannot be the same, you can realize that some babies take to pacifiers easily while some don’t.
If your baby won’t take pacifiers, there are a few tricks that can be used to make sure that he or she accepts it.
Here is one of such tricks:
Once your baby is slowly getting to the end of nursing – at that point when your baby has relaxed and his or her sucking slowed down, remove the breast and replace it almost immediately with a pacifier. wait till he or she sucks on it then pull the pacifier right back a little. You will find that your baby would respond to this by sucking even harder on the pacifier.
If you repeat this process every other day, chances are that your baby will get used to the pacifier soon enough.
Do pacifiers affect breastfeeding
Frequent use of a pacifier may lead to early weaning in your baby and if your baby isn’t well-nourished, this early weaning might have adverse effects. Also, there is a connection between the use of pacifiers in older babies and the risk of ear infections.
How to Choose the Best Pacifier for Breastfed Baby
There are several factors mainly for ease and also for the safety of your child.
Here are some of the factors.
Size (age range)
Since it would not be easy for your baby to use a pacifier that is too or too small, pacifiers are being made in different sizes and the perfect size is often determined by your baby’s age.
- Small: 0 – 6 months.
- Medium: 6 – 18 months.
- Large: 18 months and older.
The material that the pacifier’ nipple is made of is also an important feature to look out for while picking out the best pacifier for breastfed baby.
A lot of pacifier nipples feature silicone, plastic or latex.
Latex is quite soft and more flexible than other types of materials. However, it wears out easily. Also, some babies are allergic to latex so you might want to avoid buying a latex pacifier for breastfed babies if you suspect that your baby has a latex allergy.
These nipples are even sturdier than silicone and you will find that some babies prefer its solid texture.
It is quite common to find more pacifiers that feature silicone nipples than latex. Silicon is mostly dishwasher safe and they are sturdier than latex.
Bisphenol-a (BPA) nipples are hazardous to babies. Therefore, you should buy only pacifiers that are BPA free for your baby.
Easy to clean
Pacifiers with silicone nipples are easier to clean since they are dishwasher safe so you might want to look out for these or other pacifiers that are easy to clean.
Best Pacifier for Breastfed Baby Types
Since there are several pacifiers on the market, they have been divided into different categories.
Orthodontic nipple pacifier
Orthodontic nipple pacifiers usually feature a flat bottom and rounded top. This is in a bid to conform to the baby’s tongue and the baby’s mouth roof.
Natural nipple pacifier
Natural nipple pacifiers look like a small ball that is mounted on a stem. Because of this, they are often referred to as “most like mother.”
Verdict and Recommendation for 2020
Picking the perfect pacifier for your baby is very important as getting an unsuitable one could end up affecting your baby instead of comforting him or her. Our pick for the best pacifier for breastfed baby 2020 is the MAM Night Pacifiers (2 Count) 0-6 Months. The pacifier has soft nipples that the natural feel of skin thereby making it as close to the breast as possible. It also features little openings that Bette ventilation for your baby. Additionally, this pacifier comes with a sterilizing storage case that helps in cleaning of the pacifier. Lastly, the pacifier has the glow-in-the-dark feature that makes it easy for parents to locate even the darkness. Thus, at top-mom.com, the overall best baby pacifier is MAM Night Pacifiers.