Ameda Finesse vs Spectra S2: An Ultimate Breast Pumps Comparison

Last Updated: 03 February 2021

As wonderful as it is, childbirth also brings a lot of stress to new moms! First, there is a pregnancy that is already an experience of a kind! The breastfeeding can be a challenge too. Yes, you planned to have a child, and that said, finding out that you are pregnant makes you happy! But, this doesn’t change the fact that the changes to your body and mind can be hard to handle! The choice between Ameda Finesse vs Spectra S2 can make the best moments really soft and touching.

And then, when you think you will explode and the baby will jump out of your belly, you finally go into labor. That moment you hold the precious bundle of joy, all the troubles that lead to his or her arrival become nothing but a distant memory. After arriving home with your beautiful baby, you believe that from that moment you and your family will only enjoy it. The reality is that you will have to choose between Ameda Finesse vs Spectra S2 to stabilize the breastfeeding process.

ameda finesse breast pump

The reality is, however, you will be confronted with a myriad of new challenges, and breastfeeding is one of them. First, regardless of everyone telling you how natural it is and how quickly you will get used to it, things are a bit more complicated. Not all babies immediately feed off the breast without problems! Additionally, some moms can experience issues such as mastitis or other that can make breast significantly complicated. Finally, we are not sure if staying at home with a baby is a privilege to begin with, but if it is considered as such, we must point out that very few women have it. Most of us are not in the situation to take such long maternity leave that allows us to stay with the child for as long as she or he is breastfed!

There is a solution for all these situations, though – breast pump! However, many new moms don’t have the experience nor the time to choose the best breast pump that can guarantee to satisfy their needs. That’s where we come to the rescue! Since we understand how it is to be in your shoes, we consulted experts and experienced moms to learn about breast pumps. As a result, we created these breast pump reviews wishing they mean to you as much as they did to us!

Ameda Finesse and Spectra S2: Brief Comparison

In the text that follows, we are going to talk about different features of two popular breast pumps of 2021 – Ameda finesse and Spectra S2. You will notice there are plenty of similarities between the characteristics of these pumps, as well as some differences. These differences can be significant when you are deciding which one of these two models to buy.

Details Spectra S2 Ameda Finesse
Weight 2.9 pounds 1.1 pounds
Rechargeable No No
Battery No AA batteries
Hospital-grade Yes Yes
Pumping system Closed Closed

Ameda Finesse Overview

Ameda Finesse Breast Pump
  • CONVENIENT AND EASY: The lightweight and portable Finesse Double Electric Breast Pump features adjustable speed and suction, making it easy to set pump to perfectly fit your comfort, time and milk expressing needs. Convenient Dottie Tote bag for travel.
  • SAMPLE OUR WARES: The Ameda Finesse Breast Pump also comes with sample packs of our NoShow Premium Disposable Nursing Pads to prevent leaking that can stain your clothes, and our Store N Pour Breast Milk Storage Bags for convenient storage of breast milk.
  • SUPPORT FOR YOUR PUMPING: As part of our mission to empower you achieve your breastfeeding goals, we provide a wide suite of breast pumps, breast milk storage and nursing and pumping accessories to make your experience more comfortable, safe & convenient.
  • THE FIRST NAME IN BREAST PUMPS. Each of our highest quality breast pumps are made with what we call The Ameda Difference. Our breast pumps have been used by top healthcare institutions and millions of mothers to provide the best nutrition for their babies.
  • QUALITY BEYOND COMPARE: The Ameda Difference means we stand by our breastfeeding products. Compare Ameda's line of breastfeeding aids and pumps to products from Lansinoh, Baby Baby, bamboobies, elfinbaby, NatureBond, Milkies, Motherlove, Little Martin's.

The Ameda finesse breast pump is considered as one of the most potent models today. You can use this machine at home but also when you are traveling. That is because it can work with AA batteries as well. Weighing only 1.1 pounds it is also considered as a pretty lightweight unit. All parts of Ameda finesse have been sterilized, and you can use it straight out of a box. Since it is a hospital grade breast pump, Ameda comes with a closed system, which means that the milk cannot enter the engine regardless of what you do. The fact that the milk goes directly into the container is significant as it prevents any chance of contamination. Another reason why we like Ameda is that it comes with a lot of parts and accessories, including a bag in which you can put everything you need. The main challenge, according to Ameda finesse reviews, is that you have to change the dials each time before switching between vacuum and speed settings.

Pros & Cons

Pros Cons
  • Lightweight
  • Portable
  • Quiet
  • Safe
  • Having to change the dials is annoying and time-consuming

Spectra S2 Overview

Spectra Baby USA S2Plus Electric Breast Pump
  • Natural Nursing Technology: Our Spectra S2 electric breast pump features technology that allows comfortable suction levels that mimic the experience of natural breastfeeding as closely as possible
  • Personalized Settings: Adjust the breast pump settings to fit your preference with adjustable suction levels and two phase cycling featuring expression and massage mode
  • Single or Double Pumping: Can be used as a single electric breast pump or a double electric breast pump and for best results, authentic Spectra Baby accessories are recommended
  • BPA/DEHP Free: All Spectra pump parts that come in contact with breast milk are BPA/DEHP free, giving you peace of mind about your baby's milk
  • Made For Moms, By Moms: We`ve committed our lives to providing the best breast pumps, accessories, education, and customer care that we can, supporting every mother with the beauty of parenthood

Looking at Spectra S reviews, we notice that it is also a hospital-grade model with a closed system. One of the reasons that such a popular moms’ choice is that it is super silent. You can express milk freely without worrying about waking up the little one. It comes with an auto timer, which is vital when you forget to switch off after using it. You might be surprised now if the baby still didn’t arrive, but you will see that it can happen when you need to catch sleep whenever possible. Spectra S2 comes with a convenient handle that enables you to carry it easily wherever you go. It weighs 2.9 pounds. Spectra features a cool digital screen that shows the amount of time you spend pumping, that is something pretty convenient, especially if you are waking up in the middle of the night to pump. The massage mode makes that the extraction process is super gentle.

Pros & Cons

Pros Cons
  • Auto timer
  • Gentle extraction
  • Portable
  • Digital screen
  • Can’t run on batteries

Ameda Finesse vs Spectra S2: the Differences

Alright now, when we got informed about the general features of both pumps, let’s see the differences between Ameda finesse vs Spectra S2. As you can see, there are plenty of similarities here as well, but there are some significant differences that make them stand out each of its ways. These differences between Spectra S2 vs Ameda finesse are of interest because they can determine which of the two models is more appropriate for your particular needs.

  • The first dissimilarity you notice when you review Ameda vs Spectra is that the first one can run on batteries while the other one cannot. Both of them are portable indeed, but using Ameda when you are not at home might be more comfortable for this reason if you are not sure to always have access to power outlets.
  • Another thing that is different between Ameda vs Spectra breast pump is the weight. As we mentioned, Ameda weighs twice as little as Spectra.
  • The third difference between Ameda finesse vs Spectra S2 breast pump is that Spectra is equipped with a digital screen, timer, and nightlight, while Ameda isn’t.
  • Finally, the flanges are also different. Spectra features two flanges, one 24 mm in size and the other one 28 mm. Ameda, on the other hand, comes with two 25 mm and two 35 mm CustomFit flanges.


Is Electric or Manual Breast Pump Better?

In all honesty, it is hard to find a straightforward answer to this question, as there are advantages and disadvantages to both options. We can say that manual pumps are a better choice if you don’t need to pump often. They are also a good option when you are on a budget or when you want something super lightweight and portable to be able to extract the milk during your travel.

Electric pumps are, on the other hand, the best option for moms who need to pump every day or have twins. They are also convenient when you don’t have a lot of time. With a manual pump, you are expressing by hand, so reasonably, it more time than with an electric that does the job in 15-20 minutes. Also, an electric breast pump allows you to do other things because your hands are free.

When to Express My Breast Milk?

Generally speaking, it indeed depends on your personal choices and needs. But, yes, some situations entail that you use a breast pump. Moms who have to return to work, but don’t want to switch to formula benefit from the possibility to express. Also, if your breasts are engorged or you have some health issues, the expression is recommended. Additionally, some babies refuse or are unable to latch or suck for various reasons. In this case, to give a little one breast milk, you have to express.

spectra s2 brest pump

How Long Should I Pump?

A lot of women are wondering about this. In general, experts agree that the best pumping time should be about 20 minutes. They say 15 minutes is the minimum and that you should continue for 5 minutes after even if the milk stops flowing as it sends the message that you need more milk. That way supply increases over time. Keep in mind that you shouldn’t pump much more than 20 minutes.


After all this, we can say that decision on a better option between Ameda Finesse vs Spectra S2 is sort of a close call as they are both excellent breast pumps and provide all pumping benefits. Both have fantastic features – they are quiet, lightweight, portable, and they both come with a closed system. However, after researching, testing, and going through breast pump reviews 2021, we decided that the title of the winner should go to Ameda Finesse. The main reason for making this decision is that Ameda runs on batteries as well, which makes it more convenient for traveling.

Please rate this article

Current rating:
Based on 216 users feedback
Share your thoghts
Please fill required fields
Please fill required fields
Please fill required fields